Finance Q&A

Toshiba CTX670 vs Mitel SX200 , Toshiba Digital Business Telephone

Edwards Finance > Phones

Q. Looking for an 80 port business phone system with voicemail & some CTI. Value, features & reliability are important as always Have narrowed it down to the new Toshiba CTX670 and the Mitel SX200. Any views either way on these two systems?

A. CTI is not the most important thing for us. Just a nice feature if it available. ie: being able to dial a number from your outlook phone list through the phone system. Over time the Toshiba will probably cost less to own. Toshiba offers a Five Year parts warranty direct from the manufacturer to dealers. Insist from your vendor (Toshiba or Mitel) to include a written five year parts warranty. more info at www.toshiba-phones.com additional telecom resources at http://www.access-networking.com/telecom_resources.htm If I may I would like to talk about Mitel. Here in Ontario (your good friends to the North - Canada), we have seen most Toshiba disappear. The phones just do not have the functionality of the Mitel. The Mitel phone system is obviously for larger customers, as it is designed as a true PBX, where the Toshiba is more or less a key system (in my eyes anyway). When Mitel built the SX200 and the SuperSets they seriously took the "enduser/every day user" in to mind. The phones are designed with powerful features, that are truly easy to use. The display prompts are very helpful. Here was my test (keep in mind it was a Avaya Legend compared to the Mitel SX200). I put my mother down in front of the two systems and asked which ones she like the best. Mitel came out first. The functionality was programmed for the same result, but less key strokes and a more helpful display. She also like the size and look of the phones better. To this day, I have a 200 in my house, and the Legend has disappeared. In terms of programming, I like the Mitel. The Toshiba has software, although I have never seen it. The Mitel allows you to use such programs as Hyperterminal (included with Windows), PCAnywhere etc. The program takes about a month to learn (where the items are, and in which menu), but very easy to work with. The Toshiba has ##3545#854**HOLD33373## type codes. Very confusing, even to me, the technician. The code I gave does not actually work, but count all of those keys strokes, and I bet you I have less key strokes then what is actually required to program a key on a phone. This problem may or may not effect you. I once programmed a system (Toshiba) in a supermarket. The KSU (brains of the system) were about 200 feet from the phone I was using. This distance is not very far in terms of cabling. When I programmed the system (and used it to make a call after wards) I found the key strokes to be delayed and very slow, like wise with the display prompts of the screen. This is because the Toshiba system relies on the system (KSU) to do all of the work, even the DTMF's (dial sounds 1-9, 0, *, & #). On the Mitel the phone does the work - so its in real time, very alive. Finally I want to talk about the future, like the other guy did in terms of price! The Mitel *may* cost more, or *maybe* its less, I don't know how pricing is in your area. From what I know (and see on the web site) Toshiba offers nothing in terms of VoIP. VoIP is not a common thing yet (at least it is not a big part of everyday telecom yet). I see no path way, or upgrade methods for the Toshiba. Mitel is coming out with a VoIP addition (Fall 2002) that will make your SX200 VoIP compatible. That's what we call "Future Safe." No other manufacture (include Nortel, Avaya, or Toshiba) have gone as far with VoIP as Mitel. Mitel is the global leader in VoIP. Take a look that their VoIP systems (3100 and 3300 systems). These systems are VoIP based and operate on the concept of IP, not Time Division.

 


Ask Edwards a Finance Question

 

Other Questions:

Linux PBX appliances

Came across this itemWell, according to this update...

Question About ROLM PBX Telephones ?

ROLM was originally an IBM CBX / PBX voice switching venture that was in North America's arrival was purchased away from the German company SEIMENS. IBM made many advancements and improvements to the systems proprietary operating system and ar...

Post Office Phone Service ?

I've been browsing the Post Office website and came across their home phone service which has three different options for connection: 1) Deposit £10 and dial 1466 for the access code. 2) Deposit £10 and get a router box. 3) Deposit £50 and ...

New office phone system, non ISDN solution?

We will shortly be moving to a new office. We've so far made use of a fairly bog-standard ISDN PBX solution. For a number of reasons, we'd like to use only analogue lines at our new location. The requirements are: 6 separate incoming number...

Need advice on a small office phone system ?

I am building a new chiropractic office. The building will be 4224 sq. ft., of which I will occupy 2112 sq. ft.. I need a minimum of three phone lines. Three lines that trunk over, the last of which will be used with an analog fax and SBC dsl....

 

Edwards Finance Menu

Ask a Question
About Us / Me
Contact Me
Privacy Policy

Sitemap

My Favorite Sites

PFBlog
Google Finance
Yahoo Finance
Motley Fool
Nveille's Financial Blog
AllFinanceMatters
Free Money Finance
2MillionBlog
The Terror Finance blog

Q&A Subjects

Debt Recovery
Computer Engineering
Foreclosure
Architectural Engineering
Debt Help
Mortgage
Income Tax
Home Equity