Architects aren't engineers

Edwards Finance > General Engineering

Q. Should architecture courses be given on an institute of technology? Many engineers i've spoken with condemn the fact that architecture is given on a school were studies like mechanical engineering, civil engineering etc. also are given. Architecture should be given on an art school together with interior design and landscape architecture. Who agrees with this?

A. -It sounds to me as if the engineers you've spoken to are for some reason afraid of cross-discipline study. I wonder why that is? Do they feel that the "purity" of their field is somehow compromised by teaching that breaks down the traditional division between science and art? Mixing the two seems to me to be eminently sensible. -Now my experience are somwhat opposite ; the best architects say "yes ,I would like to know more about technology and computers" , and the vorse ones become hot red in their face whenever you just mention the word "computer" , ------- acturly some halve year ago, I met one who bacame that agressive that he could hardly speak, after I said that word. Now I don't blame the architect schools, but if the architects don't want to build the houses or don't want to learn using a computer , then it's their own problem, while some few years ago a lot of different branches got a new tool that replaced the tools used before, architects is in that sense no better than any other buisness where a tech tool made a nice alternative to strait edges, even working out in the forest, they stopped using flint tools many years ago, so why shuld architecture be that much different. -------- I mean if an architect know _nothing_ about mechanics ,he could suggest pietzo electric gaskets to produce energy, when a building with the weight of 10000 WTC's move with the wind ; you can even get a first price in an architect contest with that.

Ask Edwards a Finance Question

Other Questions:

Aerospace Engineering

First, I would like to thank all the ppl who have been replying to my post, the latest being the question about an NASA YF-23. If anyone has further info on it, I'll be most grateful if you email it to me. Im about to finish secondary school,...

I have receieved positive skill assessment for electrical and electronics engineering... I worked as a design engineer (electrical) in my previous employment.. will DIMIA have any problem with this as design engineer is not in their list......

Is there a book on geotechnical engineering which contain practical problems and their solutions. Topics include pile, retaining wall, bearing capacity, settlement, stability analyses, consolidation and settlement, seepage, pumping and groundw...

I an giving a talk to a group of high school students about materials science and engineering. It will be useful to have a list of interesting web sites for them to visit. The following list shows what I have so far. Can anyone suggest more s...

I am a rising senior in the U.S. who is looking at engineering colleges. I wish to get a degree in either applied physics/physics or a field in engineering, and a strong minor in econ or finance. My question is, out of the top engineering schoo...

Edwards Finance Menu

Ask a Question
About Us / Me
Contact Me
Privacy Policy

Sitemap

My Favorite Sites

PFBlog
Google Finance
Yahoo Finance
Motley Fool
Nveille's Financial Blog
AllFinanceMatters
Free Money Finance
2MillionBlog
The Terror Finance blog

Q&A Subjects